At the Best Goodie Bag all of our baked goods are made using fresh & local ingredients.
*Flavors vary week to week in store. Please call ahead for flavor selection. Prices are subject to change.
Cupcakes Single 1/2 Dozen Dozen
Reg. Cupcakes $3.50 $20.00 $36.00
Gourmet/Boozy Cupcakes $4.50 $26.00 $48.00
Flavors: Classic Vanilla; Chocolate Dream; Red Velvet, Confetti, Cookies N Cream, Caramel Apple Oatmeal, Lemon Coconut, Strawberry Lemonade, Strawberries N Cream, Red Velvet w/ Henny, Coquito, Dulce De Leche, Carrot Cake, "Hot" Chocolate, Margarita, Strawberry Margarita, Mudslide.
Cookies Each Platter
Cookies $2.00 $48.00
Flavors: Buttercrunch, Caramel Apple Oatmeal, Chocolate Chip, Cookies N Cream, Brookie, Crownie, Confetti, Oatmeal Raisin, Red Velvet, Ginger, S'mores. Cranberry Macadamia.
Cake Slice $5.00
Banana Pudding $5.00
Cake Parfaits (Cookies & Cream, Strawberry Shortcake, Pineapple Delight, Choc. Mousse, Pumpkin Pie) $4.50
per Slice Whole
Cheese Cake (Toppings: Cherry, Strawberry, Caramel Apple) $5.00 $60.00+*
Bundt Cakes (Pound, Lemon, Lemon Coconut, Carrot, Chocolate, Rum Cake) $5.00 $50.00+*
*Must be booked at least 4-7 days in advance
Italian Ices $2.00+
Ice Cream (per Scoop) $2.25
Reg. Shakes $7.25
Cake Shakes $9.25
Grandma Juice $5.50
Hot Chocolate (Seasonal) $3.00
6" Short Stack (6-8 servings) $35.00+
7" Short Stack (8-12 Servings) $45.00+
8" Short Stack (12-18 Servings) $55.00+
Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Confetti, Red Velvet, Carrot
Fillings: Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Mousse, Strawberry, Pineapple, Bavarian Cream, Vanilla Custard, Dulce De Leche, Chocolate Ganache, & German Chocolate Filling, Coconut Cream Cheese Frosting, Strawberry Cream Cheese Frosting. (Fillings are Optional & inquire an additional Fee).
Frosting: Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate Buttercream, Cream Cheese Frosting.
***Although we do try to have some ready made cakes available in store, we recommend you plain ahead & book at least 2-4 days in advance. These prices do not include custom cakes. These standard cakes are not custom decorated. To Inquire about or place an order for a Custom Cake or Treat order, please fill out our Order Request Form***
Buttery moist and dense yellow cake. Filled and frosted with our house vanilla buttercream.
Rich, fudgy chocolate cake filled and frosted with our house vanilla buttercream.
Soft like velvet, super fluffy, buttery, and moist red coloured chocolate based cake topped with a sweet cream cheese frosting.
Moist Vanilla cake with rainbow sprinkles mixed in the batter frosted with vanilla buttercream.
Luscious lemon cake made filled and frosted with our cream cheese frosting mixed with shredded coconuts.
Cookies & Cream
Moist vanilla cake baked with Oreo cookies in the batter topped with cookies & cream frosting.
Fudgy chocolate cake filled and frosted with chocolate buttercream frosting.
Fruity and sweet strawberry cake made with fresh strawberries frosted and filled with cream cheese frosting.
Moist yellow cake frosted and filled with our rich chocolate buttercream frosting.
Old fashioned rich, dense, buttery pound cake.
Sponge cake with layers of fresh macerated strawberries and whipped cream.
Old fashioned rich, dense, buttery pound cake drizzled with a fresh lemon glaze.
Dense, moist, perfectly spiced cake mixed with carrots and raisins filled and frosted with cream cheese buttercream frosting.
Dulce De Leche
Cinnamon cake, caramel filling, dulce de leche frosting.
Rich Moist Chocolate cake with a ooey gooey coconut & pecans filling.
*To order one of the above flavors for your cake, please plan ahead. Book Your orders at least 2-4 days or more in advance. To confirm availability call (516)544-8242 during normal business hours.
*Interested in a flavor that's not listed, please don't hesitate to ask us if we can accommodate your request!